But God: Facing Imposter Syndrome with the Two Best Words in Bible

Contributed by Barton Priebe, DMin, President of Northwest Baptist Seminary and author of The Problem with Christianity: Six Unsettling Questions You Have Asked and Adopted by God. Barton pastored Dunbar Heights Baptist Church in Vancouver and Central Baptist Church in Victoria before coming to Northwest.

Serving Christ comes with tremendous joys and painful hardships.  One of the hardest struggles in ministry is one we all face but rarely talk about. We call it imposter syndrome.[1]

Imposter syndrome is that awful feeling that you don’t belong in your role, despite your training and despite others endorsing you. You don’t feel good enough to do the job. You feel like someone else would be much better at it. Outwardly you may appear confident, but inwardly you feel like a fraud.

To make it worse, you fear that eventually others will see you for the imposter you feel you are. And worse still, there is rarely a safe place to talk about it. You can’t easily tell your board that you feel inadequate to lead the ministry of your church. You quietly carry on but the weight of feeling like an imposter grows heavier.

How will you deal with imposter syndrome when it rears its ugly head in your life and ministry?

A Small Word That Turns Every Story

To answer that question, I want to begin with a small word that holds more power than we realize. It is the word “but.” We use it in the middle of a sentence when we are about to say something in sharp contrast to what came before. The girl was drowning, but the lifeguard dove in and saved her. That little three letter word is the hinge on which every story turns.

Sometimes the hinge swings toward disaster. Snow White was living a good life, safe and loved, but the witch deceived her with a poisoned apple, and she fell into a sleep from which no one could wake her. Everything was going well, but then everything went wrong.

Many of us know that kind of “but” in ministry. We felt called by God.  We received training.  People affirmed our gifting and hired us to serve in a role.  But then we started to face difficulties in the role.  A voice inside began to whisper that we don’t really belong. We felt inadequate in our abilities.  As if facing our internal critic was not hard enough, we also faced the criticisms of others.  In our personal story, we felt called by God, but our story seemed to turn the wrong way as we faced seemingly impossible situations, and imposter syndrome took over our heart.

“But I” in Scripture

The Bible is filled with people who struggled with imposter syndrome as they faced difficult situations. At its root is the feeling that we are inadequate or incompetent, and it can be summarized in two words: “But I.” God calls someone to do something, and feeling unequal to the task, they reply, “But I…” followed by an excuse. They are not gifted enough, or the circumstances are too hard.

Think of Abram. God tells him he will become the father of a great nation. How does Abram respond? “But I am too old” (Genesis 17:17).

God tells Moses to go and speak to Pharaoh. Moses is full of doubt and says, “But I am not good at public speaking” (Exodus 4:10).

God tells Gideon he will deliver the Israelites from the Midianites. Gideon says, “But I am the least in my family” (Judges 6:15).

Esther must go to the king to save her people. She cannot see how the plan will work and says, “But I have not been called by the king for thirty days” (Esther 4:11).

Peter has been fishing, and Jesus tells him to cast the net on the other side of the boat. The situation seems pointless, and he says, “But I already fished all night” (Luke 5:5).

“But I” in Our Ministry

Our imposter syndrome shows up in all our “But I” statements.

  • But I am not a good enough preacher, especially compared to so and so.
  • But I am not a great visionary leader.
  • But I am not smart enough.
  • But I don’t have a charismatic personality.
  • But I just don’t know what to say when someone is grieving.
  • But I don’t know the Bible well enough to give an opinion.

How do you finish the sentence?

If you don’t learn how to deal with those deep feelings of inadequacy, you will become discouraged. Constant discouragement will eventually cause you to fall into despair. And despair will make you quit.

God Never Disagrees

So how do we face our imposter syndrome? Notice something striking: God never disagrees with people when they say they are not good enough or that the circumstances are impossible. God never says, “Moses, you’re a better speaker than you think. Just believe in yourself.”

Or consider how Paul described the Corinthians: “Brothers and sisters, think of what you were when you were called. Not many of you were wise by human standards; not many were influential; not many were of noble birth” (1 Corinthians 1:26).  In other words, not many of you had advanced degrees. None of you had a huge social media platform with millions of followers.

Paul did not go on to say, “But thankfully a few of you were rich and noble, because you are the ones God is counting on.” He did not debate the fact that the Corinthians were unimpressive. So the first step in dealing with imposter syndrome is simply to take the pressure off yourself and agree. Often you are not adequate enough or gifted enough.[1]

But then you must take the second and most crucial step.

But God

Right after those words, Paul wrote two of the best words in all the Bible. These two words are the key to facing imposter syndrome. They will save you from discouragement, despair, and quitting. The two words are “But God.”[2]

“Not many of you were wise by human standards; not many were influential; not many were of noble birth. But God chose the foolish things of the world to shame the wise; God chose the weak things of the world to shame the strong” (1 Cor 1:27-29).

Remember the hinge. In Snow White the story first turned toward darkness, but it did not end there. She lay in a sleep no one could break, but the prince came and she awoke. The same little word that turned the story toward ruin turned it back toward life.

The Canadian sports network TSN has a segment called the “TSN Turning Point.” After a game, they replay the one critical moment that turned the tide for the winning team. They were losing, but this play changed everything. The whole story of the Bible is a highlight reel of turning points, the contrast between “But I” and “But God.” It is the story of God doing impossible things through weak people.

When Joseph looked back on the darkest days of his life, after his brothers had sold him into slavery, he said, “You intended to harm me, but God intended it for good” (Genesis 50:20).

The psalmist echoes our struggle when he says, “My flesh and my heart may fail.” So often they do, when we sink into discouragement. Then he continues, “but God is the strength of my heart and my portion forever” (Psalm 73:26).

Jesus sums it up: “With man this is impossible, but with God all things are possible” (Matthew 19:26).

The King Has Another Move

There is a famous story about the great chess champion Paul Morphy. He was invited to the home of some notable chess players for an evening of games. During dinner, his attention was drawn to a painting hanging prominently on the wall. It was the work of the German artist Friedrich Retzsch, inspired by the legend of Faust.

In the painting, the devil sits across a chessboard from a young man named Faust. They are playing for Faust’s soul. The devil’s black pieces represent vices, and Faust’s white pieces represent virtues. Faust has only a few pieces left. He has not played the game of life wisely and has sinned greatly. His situation looks hopeless, and his fate appears sealed, for the devil has one final move and it will be checkmate. You can see the despair on Faust’s face.

Many chess players had studied the board in that painting and agreed: it was checkmate.

When Morphy finished his dinner, he walked up to the painting and studied it intently for some time. Then he suddenly exclaimed, “The king has another move!” The other guests protested. “That’s impossible. Not even you can save Faust’s game.” But Morphy said, “I can.”

They brought out a chessboard and arranged the pieces exactly as they appeared in the painting. Everyone gathered around. To their astonishment, Morphy moved the king and then played a succession of moves that snatched victory from the devil and saved the soul of Faust.

That is the gospel. Ephesians 2:1 says we were “dead in our trespasses and sins.” We were not merely sick, needing to take better care of ourselves so that we would heal. We were dead. Checkmate. After three verses of describing our helpless and hopeless state, Paul dramatically introduces the hinge statement where everything changes: “But God, who is rich in mercy, made us alive with Christ” (Ephesians 2:4).  What we could not do for ourselves, God did for us through His Son. When everyone else looked at the board and saw only defeat, the King had another move.  If God can rewrite the cosmic story from ruin to restoration, surely he can rewrite our smaller stories too, turning our “But I” excuses in life and ministry into “But God” moments that carry us through what feels impossible.

Preach “But God” to Your Own Heart

You will face imposter syndrome throughout your life and ministry. It will overtake you, and you will hear yourself say, “But I am not smart enough. But I am not a good enough leader. But I am not a good enough speaker,” along with a thousand other “But I” statements.

When that happens, start by agreeing. Then preach the gospel to your own heart. But God has put me in this role. But God gives wisdom generously to those who lack it. But God has said, “My grace is sufficient for you, for my power is made perfect in weakness” (2 Corinthians 12:9). And then stand up and do the task He has called you to do.

Who Knows How Your Story Will Go?

None of us knows how our own story will unfold. Our lives and ministries will be filled with hardship. There will be chapters where the pages grow dark and it looks as though the devil has only one move left until we are in checkmate. But who knows what God will do?

In Peter Jackson’s movie adaptation of J.R.R. Tolkien’s The Two Towers, Sam Gamgee reflects to Frodo that the great stories, the ones that really mattered, were full of darkness and danger. Sometimes you didn’t even want to know how they ended, because it seemed impossible that the end could be happy after so much had gone wrong. Yet Sam insists that the shadow is only a passing thing. “Even darkness must pass,” he says, and when the new day comes, the sun will shine all the clearer.[2]

Sam is right that darkness does not get the final word. The gospel does promise that one day God will make all things new. But our hope is not only for the future and great “but God” day of Christ’s second coming.  The same God who wrote “But God” into the stories of Joseph, Esther, and Peter is at in our present lives to do things that we could never imagine.  He turns the seemingly impossible into the possible, closed doors into open ones, and weak servants into empowered witnesses. We may be inadequate in many ways but God “is able to do immeasurably more than all we ask or imagine, according to His power that is at work within us (Ephesians 3:20).

When you feel like an imposter, when the circumstances look impossible, when your heart and your flesh fail, remember the hinge on which your story turns. But God!

Notes

[1] The overall thoughts in the “But I” and “But God” contrast in the above paragraphs were inspired by John Ortberg, Steps: A guide to transforming your life when willpower isn’t enough (Illinois: Tyndale Refresh, 2025), 35-42.
[2] Samwise Gamgee in The Lord of the Rings: The Two Towers Directed by Peter Jackson (New Line Cinemas, 2002).

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *